Welcome to Macy’s Place Pizzeria
Welcome to Macy’s Place Pizzeria, a delightful addition to Williamsville, NY, located at 8885 Main St. Known for its friendly service and vibrant atmosphere, this pizzeria boasts a menu brimming with classic pizzas and creative options, like the unforgettable mac and cheese onion ring pizza. Customers rave about the generous portions and flavorful wings, especially the bourbon chivetta’s. The puffy, crisp crust and quality toppings make the pizza stand out, although some noted a sweeter sauce preference. As you step inside, the warm, clean decor invites you to stay and savor a memorable meal. Dive into this local gem!
Macy’s Place Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
I wanted to pop over and Welcome Macy’s to the area! My family was excited to give them a-go once they opened & today was the day! 1st hats off to all the workers for busting their butts today! They were absolutely slammed & did all they could to fill everyone’s orders. 2nd- The Food. We ordered their Large Pizza & 20 wings special. We went traditional for our first pie (Cheese and Pepperoni). Great crust- puffy & with crisp to it, pepperoni was good thicker slice with lots of flavor, cheese was good too. OUR only take away on the pie was the sauce is a little on the sweeter side for our liking. This WILL NOT STOP us from ordering again. ;0) 20 WINGS- 1/2 burbon chivetta’s, 1/2 medium—both crispy. Not a bad thing to say here- both sauces were fantastic. We really liked the burbon chavetta’s- sweet tangy char sauce!! Medium was good- very traditional medium- could have been a little saucier. Wings served with Ken’s BC. 3. Interior- is cleaned up and paint updated. I will note it was hot in there. Poor staff looked beat. But with the order’s they were whipping out - it doesn’t surprise me how warm it was. Be patient people—-Give them some time to work out the kinks- it’s opening week. Job well done!
Very friendly and clean the pizza was really good with a really good sauce and toppings. I got the " weekend and grammies". My only complaint is it feels really awkward as an adult man to order that. Like you go in to pick it up and have to say "him I'm here for my weekend at grammies" it just feels weird lol. This is my 3rd time at a macys they have all been good exspences and first time at this newer location. There menue has many unique interesting looking options sadly my spouce isn't as adventurous about trying things so try the more unusual ones for me. Good job yall glad to see a small business making it!
Best pizza we have had in a very long time. Portions are generous. BBQ wings were well cooked (not on the under done side) so the BBQ sauce did not make them soggy. Our build a pizza was a bit complicated and the young lady at the counter made sure she took the order correctly. The young lady at the counter was very busy but still managed to remain happy and helpful.
My kid loves this place and asks what stick is in the neon lady’s (Macy’s) mouth. Mario and Luigi are a nice touch! I like to call our order ahead and my kid loves sitting at those tables.
The service is always fast and friendly, and the pizza is phenomenal. Also the mac and cheese / onion ring pizza is lifechanging - highly recommend.
Omgosh! Why did I wait so long to go here!? I highly recommend the Joe dirt Pizza! I ate one slice and I think I need a nap!
Got 2 pizzas recently, they were fantastic. Staff was nice, we ordered right before closing and they didn't give any issues. Definitely recommend!
I work closer to Wehrle and Gunville, so going out for lunch usually means heading all the way to Transit... well, I'll tell you what... this new location? My doctor probably won't be happy, but I sure am! Stopped in on Tuesday and Thursday for lunch and the pizza (cheese & pep) and wings (medium) with a can of pop lunch special was amazing. They may have just opened, but it's their third location - not their first rodeo. Classic Buffalo pizza - thick cheese, semi-thick crust, cup & char pepperoni. Their sauce, I think, is a little on the sweeter side, which I love on this style pizza. Wings were fresh, crispy, and the medium sauce is what I consider "classic" for Buffalo, which is my personal favorite. Served with Ken's blue cheese, which I don't really care for, but it was fine. I ordered online both times, planning to get there just before noon and managed to grab a small booth to sit at. I think that there are only 3 booths that would fit 4 people each, as well as 1 small, 2-person booth. I didn't even notice the first time, but the second time I think I noticed some outdoor seating, as well. Service was great, too. Only thing that didn't work well was the garbage situation. Slices and lunch specials are served in sturdy, cardboard pizza boxes that are probably 12x12, maybe a little bigger, and when you're done with them there is one garbage can and it fills up quick. Also, parking can be a little scarce when it is busy. I chose to park in the lot behind it and walk over. One of these days I'll branch out into the subs and salads for lunch or take a specialty pizza home, but I can tell you for certain that the staples are solid.
Location
-
8885 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221, United States Hotline: +1 716-932-7007
Welcome to Macy’s Place Pizzeria, your new go-to destination for delicious pizza and comfort food in the heart of Williamsville, NY. Located at 8885 Main St, this vibrant eatery has quickly captured the hearts—and taste buds—of locals since opening its doors. Their phone number, +1 716-932-7007, will soon be your most-dialed as you crave their irresistible offerings.
The buzz surrounding this pizzeria is palpable. Customers like Kristen Cummings have already praised the hardworking staff, who, even during a bustling opening week, manage to whip up quality meals with a smile. Cummings highlights the large cheese and pepperoni pizza as a testament to Macy’s dedication to tradition. The pizza is characterized by its puffy yet crispy crust and a robust pepperoni that delivers on flavor. While the sauce tends to lean a bit sweeter for some, it's clear this won't deter the faithful from returning for more.
In addition to their pies, the wings have also received rave reviews. Diners have loved trying out flavors like bourbon chivetta's and classic medium, noting the crispy texture and tasty sauces. Catherine Raichel emphasizes how the wings remain perfectly cooked and not overly soggy, reflecting the kitchen's commitment to quality. This attention to detail resonates with diners who appreciate both flavor and proper cooking techniques.
If you're feeling adventurous, consider trying their signature mac and cheese and onion ring pizza, a unique fusion that left Matt Dubois utterly impressed, describing it as "life-changing." Macy’s menu is filled with inventive options that cater to both the traditionalist and the more adventurous eater.
Upon walking in, you will be met with a clean and inviting interior—a fresh space that feels welcoming. The playful decor elements, including a neon lady and nods to classic gaming icons like Mario and Luigi, add a fun twist that makes dining here a unique experience, especially for families. Andrea Claire captures this spirit when she mentions how her child loves visiting the pizzeria. There’s a sense of community here that is palpable and nourishing.
As Macy’s Place Pizzeria settles into its routine, it is clear they are committed to creating a memorable dining experience. With a blend of friendly service, inventive menu items, and a cozy atmosphere, it’s no wonder that patrons are eager for repeat visits. Overall, Macy’s is more than just a pizzeria; it’s quickly becoming a beloved local treasure, and I can’t wait to return to indulge in their delicious offerings.